Hi! Welcome to the “Annoying Villagers Fan theories!” I'm your host, Wookieaaaa here you can post theories about the series!
When writing please make it a Section and Write the theory title on the heading. Like seen below. But first please read the rules
- All theories have to be associated with annoying villagers: I know this is an obvious one, but it happened at the FNAF wiki.
- Be Nice!: All the theories posted must be nice and not inappropriate.
- Do Not delete the Debunked on one of your theories: If you have a Debunked on one of your theories it means that it can't make sense what so ever.
- If you see a Confirmed on one of your theories - congratulations! Your guess was apparently proven right by Annoying Villagers.
- If you see a Likely to be Confirmed or Likely to be Debunked or Likely to remain a mystery, that means exactly that - it will be likely confirmed or debunked in the future, or it may very likely never be looked at again. Sorry about that if you got a "Likely to remain a mystery".
- Sorry for the walls of ranting text I will occasionally drop on your head if your theory makes no sense in advance - Jutpa
- Also, I will not put such "Likely to be Confirmed/be Debunked/remain a mystery" on my theories. Go put that on yourself.
The True Herobrine (Sure...)[]
Posted by: The Bot Medic
I think this image is pretty self-explanatory but I'll go into more in-depth detail about it. In Episode 36 Basically, after Boop did his 'Super Mega Ultimate' move on Armored Herobrine, it cut to this scene.
And it revealed a Herobrine Vessel that looks exactly like Island Herobrine (Or Forest Herobrine) standing in the Vessel Realm observing Boop and Notch.
Not only was this the primary default skin of Herobrine, but he was observing throughout Armored Herobrine Vessel's mind. Only Herobrine's that transfer energy or/and are given orders speak throughout each other's mind. But this was a SINGLE Herobrine that was directly communicating with Armored Herobrine and observing ALONE.
It seems that this Herobrine was observing throughout Armored Herobrine vessel's mind, as all Herobrine Vessels are connected throughout a hive mind, and each Vessel are symbiotes (Like in the movie VENOM) manifesting with a Player having their own abilities.
Now, to be quite frank, I think this is the True Herobrine or/and Island Herobrine for the above solid reasons.
EDIT: The True Herobrine has been revealed on Episode 51.
My thoughts regarding User's theories[]
Posted by: The Bot medic
Here are my thoughts regarding Paolo, DaRealWaluigi, and Unknown User's theories.
The Fall of The Resistance| PaoloGaming HD's theory
Greg will definitely not die. It was shown beforehand that Greg brings up valid excuses such as 'scouting' to communicate with the Herobrine Forces, which was likely in this case to track down the Blue Demon. Burrito and Greg's name not being on there was purposely because MrFudge wanted to include other people on the signs.
Zherterry is a Herobrine Doppelganger| DaRealWaluigi's theory
Zherterry is not a doppleganger. It was obvious before that he respawned in the future as a normal Player. And now it's 100% confirmed, since he's no longer a Patreon XD
Light Shadow Herobrine is the true Herobrine| Unknown User's Theory
Firstly Light Shadow Herobrine isn't the true Herobrine just because of the way he acts. Plus he's the same person as Shadow Herobrine, so it's false.
Shadow Herobrine from episode 30/34 is the Herobrine from the island| DaRealWaluigi's Theory
It was already false that Shadow Herobrine can't be Island Herobrine before it was revealed, because they have different textured skins.
The Illager King and the other Illagers are apart of the United Mob Association plus Reaperbrine| Unknown User's Theory
The Illager King can't be a part of the United mob association because the Illager Forces work with the Herobrine Forces. It also hasn't been confirmed whether the Drowned betrayed the UMA nor has it been mentioned. Plus it seems he still is given he works with animals and has a devoted goal.
Just because Reaper Herobrine doesn't use obsidian does not at all make him the true Herobrine... Null was a doppleganger and he didn't use obsidian. Also, having eyebrows means nothing at all. The Herobrine that freed the Drowned when he was a Zombie also said that the world needed to be cleansed, since all Herobrines follow the same ideal.
The Fall of The Resistance (Likely to be Confirmed, except no, because they're in their really old camp in this observation, except yes, because they are already in absolute shambles and Greg is absolutely DED)[]
Posted by: PaoloGamingHD
Remember this scene in annoying villagers 42? My theory is that this observation is in the future when almost all the players of the resistance are wiped out or dead. That only three of them survived: Grave, BingoBear and My_Mustacheo
Which also means that Greg Herobrine might die and one of the reasons he does not appear here.
Okay you might say "Oh look at the sign idiot Greg's name is not written there" Yeah i know but did you noticed that Burrito's name is not also in the signs.
The next question to this is why? Im not so sure but it could be of the arising dangers in the world. We will know this in the future episodes
The Reaper Herobrine theory. (I don't even know) (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
Posted by: Lord Kookooness
So in Annoying Villagers Reaper Herobrine was holding his staff in episode 33 both in the storyline past and future, while at the time when the Blue Demon killed Herobrine number 7, Reaper Herobrine was holding a sword. This was at a time between Reaper Herobrine holding his staff while creating the blue demon and when he took back the Ender dragon the drowned killed in the observation in episode 33. This will be because Reaper Herobrine had at first upgraded his staff to a sword, and (just predictions) would, in the future, fight steve with it. Then the Blue Demon would join, and BBQ would also join eventually. In the fight, Steve’s legendary sword will be destroyed, and the Blue Demon would also use up his tridents. Just then, BBQ hops in, and protects the Blue Demon from a strike of Reaper Herobrine’s sword with his beak, since there must be a reason that the Villager Scout in episode 37 mentioned it was as hard as a diamond sword. But as an only powerful but only slightly important character to the plot, BBQ would die, and the Blue Demon would be overwhelmed with emotion. He will then use a very powerful move of some kind to strike Reaper Herobrine, but the killing blow will be delivered with Steve’s legendary sword. Reaper Herobrine would be dead, and so the Herobrine that took back the Ender Dragon in the observation would be a different one, wielding Reaper Herobrine’s old staff. This theory is based off the ideas of a person called “水豹绵绵”, (don’t translate it, since it’s actually his nickname), and he really does have truly genius predictions of Annoying Villagers. He even predicted that Mrfudgemonkeyz’s storyline’s merging with Alex’s storyline all the way back in February 2020!
Herobrine number 7 theory (Confirmed, I guess?)[]
Posted by: Lord Kookooness
the Herobrine number 7 that the Drowned killed is the one Alex met, so Alex did not defeat Herobrine in their encounter or get transformed into a doppelgänger. This is because when Herobrine number 7 was killed, the player left behind looks identical to a player in the Purple Banana of Death, and then back then some
members of Purple Banana tried to attack null, so maybe he possessed one of them.
Drowned used to work for Herobrine (Confirmed as of AV43)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
From left to right: Herobrine, The Drowned and X_Grave_X. (credit to Wookieaaaa)
I think The drowned used to work of herobrine, here's why, the drowned told Steve to not use his items (sword,armor ect) who else doesn't use items? Herobrine! Also he knows a lot about what's around him, such as, knowing what happens when mobs die.
The White Eyed Demon in Av25 Conspiracy Theory (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
Posted by: The Bot Medic
When The White Eyed Demon Said that “I just need one more,” he didn’t mean killing ONE more villager. He (or she, whatever The White Eyed Demon is) was sending one by one, MORE villagers to the Villager kingdom.
Each time, he carries a message with him, and speaks it to every Villager of who‘s village has been raided and destroyed by The White Eyed Demon himself and HEROBRINE.
he says: “We players. We seek to declare war. War with the Villager King.” Now, here’s the thing: I DON’T
The Villager is forced by The White Eyed Demon to run and tell the Villager King his “message.”
THINK HE’S ACTUALLY A PLAYER. He only said that to make the villagers declare war with the players, making them think that players slaughter them and carry the same message with them to bring them pain and suffering.
It’s just like Steve said: “Why can’t you see? There are no true winners in the game of war...”
Null is the true Herobrine (Debunked as of AV51)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
I believe that Null is the true herobrine. Most players say Herobrine as " the white eyed demon " and the only character that looks identical to the white eyed demon is Null, this confirms that Null is not his official name, it's the white eyed demon player. And no player ( except steve ) calls Herobrine herobrine, the Herobrines are represented as the white eyed demon, so the true herobrine... Is actually Null, also in stories Herobrine is also represented as the white eyed demon.
The True Herobrine is the one that converted Greg and Chris (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
Posted by: LuismiPro465
While Null is used as the portrait of the legend, it may just mean he's the only one that shows himself to players and villagers without killing them all, leaving witnesses, while all the other Herobrines, as seen with the one who fought Grave, destroy (or try to) every player and villager they find in their way.
Now, we shall go back to the beggining. When Steve's team got defeated, Greg and Chris were converted into Herobrines by Herobrine. I am positive that HE's the True Herobrine, as when Chris was defeated, the Witch called him "Herobrine #3". That means that Chris was the third Herobrine to ever exist, just as Greg is the second one. Thus, the one that converted both of them into Herobrines MUST be the True One.
Now, the Herobrine that fights Grave isn't the original Herobrine, as he was seen speaking to the True one via telepathy. The fake Herobrines seem to develop differences from the other ones, such as their own skills. This Herobrine must have been recently transformed, as he had the standard Herobrine skills (High speed, reflex and obsidian manipulation), such as Chris still hadn't developed either.
On the other hand, we've got Greg, who developed his own skill as a Herobrine, which is being able to transform to his player skin. We've also got Shadow Herobrine, who has developed his obsidian manipulation skills and also his obsidian, "enhancing" it, hence its glow. There's also Armored Herobrine, who has developed high defence and resistance due to his armor and some obsidian poles through his body, while also having more skilled obsidian manipulation.
For last, we've got Null, who is the only Herobrine that leaves witnesses, forcing them to return to their base/kingdom with a war message, stating that either, players or villagers want to declare war on each other. Thus, why the legends are about him. Also, to make people not know what to think. Null developed high long-range skills, although being weak on close combat.
MrFudgeMonkeyz animated shorts are the Future of annoying villagers (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
What if, fat Herobrine and the animated shorts are the future? It uses the same characters as annoying villagers, AND the characters keep their personality. Certaint events prove that it's the future such as,
- Steve achieves peace and becomes the mayor of what was his guarding ground and retires of being a hero.
- Grave holds his grudge against Steve and teams up with an old enemy.
- Herobrines forces die and the true Herobrine preserves his power as a somewhat hostile creature.
Of course, a LOT of this is speculation of what might have happened, but it does make sense.
Eddie is Eddie?! (Who is who?!) Plus the mystery of what’s in the “Swamp.”And Boop. Also, “The Drowned!” (Partly Debunked - wait no, actually FULLY DEBUNKED as the Drowned is actually a traitor to UMA, the Swamp is the main base of the UMA, and the Swamp is also kind of really good at being targeted by weak piglins that get deleted from existence by an unarmored player)[]
Eddie in Av29?
Eddie in Av31!
Um... Yea, a lot of THEORIES COMING RIGHT AT YA! First things first: are these the same “Eddie?” Well, we all know that the timelines of Annoying Villagers are split between the main antagonists and protagonists: (Steve, Boop, Villager in the Blue/Black Rode, Alex and Herobrine). But, I can’t tell if these two events in Av29 and Av31 happened in the Past or the Future!
I also can’t tell if this derpy version of Eddie in Av29 is the same as the one in Av31, 32 and 36! Why does this even matter? Because this means that Eddie is supposedly guarding the Swamp and working for Herobrine!
Well, maybe it IS the same Eddie that’s guarding the swamp. But wouldn’t that mean Eddie WORKS for Herobrine! Well, NO. Mabye Eddie is just guarding the Swamp to make sure nobody finds out what’s in there before Boop does!
This topic has really been bugging me for a while. WHAT IS IN THE SWAMP!!!! Well, anyways it must be of importance off Herobrine, since “The Witch” said not to let Boop and Mrfudgemonkeyz (plus Steve and Charlie the Creeper) Get to the swamp. It also must have something to do with Herobrine’s powers, of whom Boop currently possesses.
You see, Steve the llama also wants to get to the Swamp too! Steve the llama probably sees Boop as a STRONG and POWERFUL asset to the ANIMAL/MOB ASSOCIATION. Maybe that secret “thing” in the swamp will make Boop EVEN STRONGER! On a side note I totally want to see Boop BASH UP more bad guys! #SuperMegaUltimante.
I also think that when Boop is recruited in the organisation (along with Mrfudgemonkeyz) he will meet “The Drowned.” But when Boop and Mrfudgemonkeyz find out The Drowned killed Steve, they will be infuriated, knowing that Steve tried to saved their lives (In Av12)! And so, they FIGHT! Or, at least Boop will. Mrfudgemonkeyz will probably get knocked out AGAIN! LOL. Well, hopefully Mrfudgemonkeyz will finally find out that Boop actually has “super powers”and all of what Boop said was actually true. I can just imagine his expression when he finds out the “TRUTH.”
What's In The Swamp Theory (Likely to be Confirmed)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
I believe that what's in the swamp is the united mob association base, I mean, there's been no official confirmation saying why there going to the swamp. However, there has been hints toward it, like Steve the llama saying " Eddie you protect these two and BRING THEM TO MASTER " this confirms that there possibly going to see one of the top members ( probably #1 ) . Now he also said that " they" are watching, who are they? I believe it's now Joe the pufferfish and possibly the Drowned Zombie God. Now if we look at the Timeline we know that joe has not yet come to capture the villager in the black robe.
The people at the end of Av38 are the hoodie brothers [DEBUNKED][]
One guy there looked like one of the hoodie bros but i dunno about the other guy. Also, they said they wanted to help Steve in Av23 and 27. This is just a theory but hopefully it turns out to be true.
NOTE: I don’t think this is going to be the case anymore since their names are different.
Edit: These people are actually different. Mr. Colder and Enchanter.
Notch Doesn't care about the world theory (Likely to be Debunked)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
Notch seems like a good guy right? But what if, he's the true villain? He is wise as seen in episode 11, but why would he send the villager in the blue robe to fix the world? Also be tells Boop and MrFudgeMonkeyz to just figure out how to stop Herobrine! He doesn't take it seriously, and Herobrine says that he will make the world into a utopia, and also, Herobrines very right about notch being incompedent, he doesn't take it seriously cuz he doesn't care! He is just toying with them,he is the true villain, it's just like what Herobrine said: he will lead this world to its very destruction,
Note: I do not think this is true, it's just he to make you think a different way!
Burrito's "message" At The End Of Av36 Could be sayin' Something about Grave... (Likely to be Debunked)[]
"Beware. Beware of your desires. Your desires for power. Don't let it consume you. It will be your downfall."
Posted by: The Bot Medic
At the end of 36, Moist Burrito, who was de-possessed by Armored Herobrine, said something to Boop about "beware of your desires for power. Don't let it consume you it will be your downfall."
And... You all know some arrogant player who's both the leader of the "Resistance" and friend of Burrito himself. GRAVE! And what does Grave want the most? EXACTLY! POWER!!!! I remember in Annoying Villagers 20 he wanted to take Herobrine's power into his control. And the only reason Herobrine number 2 didn't kill him was because Burrito sacrificed himself!
The only reason BOOP himself wasn't consumed by Herobrine's power in Av 13 was because he is carefree, unknowing and does not want power. He is basically a mere, derpy villager that got thrown into some wild and wacky adventure!
My point is... Will the reason Grave meet his end because of his mere longing for POWER!?!?
Greg's secret message DECODED (what?) (it is a codeword, not a literal coded message, the entry in the chat is known by Grave to mean that there is something coming that ain't no player but also ain't no villager either)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
Something that has always bothered me is Greg's secret message, WHAT IS IT ACTUALLY SAYING?!?! Well I think certainly numbers an letters mean something, like egg is some,and 347 is thing, now there isn't enough numbers/ letters for the whole thing could be grave exaggerating, but it could also mean that it is the whole thing, so I think that it's shortened. For the entire thing to fit.
Drowned is Notchs reincarnation. (NO.) (Likely to be Debunked)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
So what if, the drowned is notch's reincarnation? We know that Notch's physical form is deceased, but not his energy, and the drowned has seen Steve's legendary sword, so maybe he remembers giving Steve that sword, and possibly the reason he knows how he is so strong, and Steve said the the drowned reminds him of notch. And also that could be the reason why he knows that mobs reincarnate, we know that mobs reincarnated because the drowned said to the iron golem warior " I pray you find light in your next life".
Burrito will come back theory (Likely to remain a mystery, although there is a high chance it may end up Confirmed!)[]
Posted by: Villager Knight
So where to start.... The same thing that happened to Chris, it also happened to burrito. He died becoming a Herobrine, so did burrito! He died leaving his herobrine form, so did burrito! And since Chris got respawned by Notch (Additional Info: he set his spawn location so he doesn’t spawn near the villager kingdom), so could burrito?
Shadow Herobrine possessed Alex (Debunked as of AV58)[]
Posted by: Bonzipods
In episode 29, Jev explained that Alex was fighting Shadow Herobrine, but he fell off a tree so he doesn't know who won. Maybe Shadow Herobrine killed Alex and turned her into a Herobrine doppelganger? We know that Greg can change into his original skin while being possesed, so why can't Alex? Plus, Herobrine Doppelgangers are usually experienced players right?Moist Burrito, Chris and Greg are all Strong Players, and so Alex could be possessed.
Armoured Herobrine is the same Herobrine from episode 25 [DEBUNKED][]
So.... the herobrine from Episode 25 could be armoured Herobrine because the Herobrine from Episode 25 got Dark Obsidian poles inside his body from Shadow Herobrine and still appears the same in Episode 31. Plus, Burrito was (I’m not sure about Episode 25 one) both of them.
Rank 3 of mob association is a Vindicator or Wandering Trader (Confirmed - the Illager King isn't a vindicator or wandering trader, but he is an illager with an axe)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa And Villager Knight
So pretty short theory, the rank 3 looks like a villager with an axe. And the wandering trader is technically not a villager.
no u
Zherterry is a Herobrine Doppelganger (NO.) (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
Posted by: Wookieaaaa
So Zherterry got killed by shadow Herobrine, so what if he is a Herobrine Doppelganger, we know that Greg can switch from having pupils to having white eyes.
Light Shadow Herobrine is the true Herobrine (Debunked as of AV51)[]
Ok so Light Shadow Herobrine is like a lil bit of every Herobrine we have seen, his mouth doesn't move, he is half of a herobrine, and half black.
Shadow Herobrine from episode 30/34 is the Herobrine from the island (DE. BUNKED.)[]
Posted by:Wookieaaaa
Ok so Shadow Herobrine attacked the purple banana clan, but at the time there was only 1 or 2 Herobrines, if the Herobrine from the island is the original then that would mean that that shadow Herobrine just be either the Herobrine from the island of the true Herobrine, because Herobrines power was just growing.
Steve, Alex, and the united mob association united. (Likely to be Confirmed - Steve is already appearing to be more allied with UMA (or at least was until Angry Steve happened), and Alex is kind of in their territory and helping Boop out)[]
Posted by: DonaldTrumpppppp
We know that Alex was at the swamp while following the Enderman, We also know that in ep.38, Steve determined that he's the one neede to change, and somehow end up in the UMA. Plus the good people's main storyline only includes 3 parts: Alex, Steve, and boop. Steve and boop has met before, Alex and boop will meet(if Alex was discovered and nothing bad happens, I suppose it would happen around ep 40-45), then why can't Alex and Steve meet together and become close comrades like Eddie the Enderman and Steve the Llama? plus the event where Steve fight with the Drowned was at midnight. although real Minecraft night time is 20 minute, steve and other characters still feels like it is passing through like 24 hours per day. Thus it doesn't make sense that Steve can stay alive for 6 hours straight because the drowned didn't give him the chance to regenerate health. so I suppose The Drowned decided to spare Steve and let him learn his lesson by manipulation his mind by electrifying him, causing Steve to have illusions. Steve might realize that and allow the drowned to become his teacher. Now, with Steve learning his lessons, and the addition of Notch's power, they might stand a chance against the Herobrine army and give peace to the world!
Grave and My_Mustachio's downfall (Likely to be Debunked) (Except no, it is already kind of DEBUNKED because Herobrine Greg is now NUKED)[]
Posted by: DonaldTrumpppppp
As we know, Grave wanted to possess the power of Herobrine in ep20 and seeks vengeance against Steve, My_Mustachio seeks vengeance towards Alex, also Greg is the minion of Herobrine, so if the final war comes which includes the UMA, Alex, and Steve, Greg might persuade them to become Herobrine's minion, and even the purple_bow_user guy told them not to, they accepted the deal and was controlled by Herobrine. They attacked Steve and Alex while Boop and MrFudgeMonkeyz gain the power of Notch to go against the main body of Herobrine. In the end, the army of Herobrine, Including affected Greg, Grave, and My_Mustachio died. Greg said the last words to Steve and died while Grave and My_Mustachio realizes their mistake then dies. Just before Grave died, he gives the leadership of the player union to the Purple_Bow_User and that guy left. one Herobrine's copy might escape and continue this episode!
The Illager King and the other Illagers are apart of the United Mob Association (Confirmed as of AV53) (Reaper Herobrine theory debunked as of AV51)[]
Maybe, The Illager King is apart of the UMA and the reason why the illagers referred The Drowned as a traitor, is because he betrayed the UMA and went on his own. I don’t entirely know about this because the Pillagers were once working with Zombies, and the UMA doesn’t like Zombies, but who knows...
Reaper Herobrine is the true Herobrine. Here's why: you see the Herobrine's that use obsidian are doppelgangers. However, Reaper Herobrine does not use obsidian. Also, he is the one who saved the zombies in the xp farm. He is also the one who trained the zombies to fight. Also, he actually has eyebrows. The other Herobrinez dont . In episode 43, Reaper herobrine says t o the zombie s that the world needs to be cleansed.
Chris, Greg and Steve will meet one day (Likely to be Confirmed) (Also Greg got saved by Blue Demon nuking him into oblivion)[]
posted by: a Fandom User
right now the three are seperated, but one day they'll have to team up one day.
- First, Greg can't be a Herobrine doppoanger forever! He might be saved by what could be steve, because in AV49 the drowned was heading his direction by a sign Fuzzy cloud made, and also, Steve can't always go alone with the drowned forever, so they'll have to meet.
- Secondly: The three are best friends and partners, Chris now has his own clan and when they team up, they'll have enough power.
- Third: The storyline that it's leading to is that, first Steve saves greg, then they both go and find Chris and protect this world.
The resistence clan and the Aliance clan will have a war (Likely, wait no, not even likely, just plain old CONFIRMED) (Except the Resistance barely exists now and the Villager Kingdom is about to be absolutely yeeted by the United Mob Association anyways)[]
Both clans are enemies, in AV?? It is seen that both clans have different thinkings, and the aliance clan is really a big disdurbence for the Risistance clan, The Aliance first tried to stop grave from getting the wandering trader, then they teamed up with many villagers and formed a great threat for the Resistance, so if grave wants to stop this, he'll have to battle with Chris's clan. Also grave said they were forced into the desert and they'll have to fight back, however Chris doesn't want to fight, he wants to protect and aliance but grave don't.
Boop's Zombie Pigman and Netherite Zombie Piglin (Debunked as of AV58, the netherite zombie piglin is unseen, but Alex was the one who had to protect Boop from the piglins) (Also I am theorising right here but I don't think we will see that zombie piglin again, also just look at Boop and then look at the 1.14 Villagers - they're technically still villagers and in a normal Minecraft world the update would transform the pre-1.14 villagers but they're seperate so the pigman should still be a pigman)[]
By: Baryonyx
In AV 45, there's a powerful Zombified Piglin, who pops out from a nether portal (right before the end of the episode), seemingly hunting for something. Now here's the theory: The Netherite Zombie Piglin is the exact same figure as the Zombie Pigman Boop spawned several episodes ago, because due to the new update, Zombie Pigmen transform into Zombified Piglins. The Zombified Piglin might've appeared from the portal to serve Boop again and protect him from Alex.
The True Herobrine is a Creator (Confirmed as of AV51)[]
By: Baryonyx
The True Herobrine is still a mystery in AV, in fact, many people theorizes who is the real Herobrine. Whoever's the real Herobrine is, in my theory, he is a Creator. Here's why.
- Dinnerbone refers Herobrine as a second-rate Creator in Annoying Villagers 50, though since he told Steve that everyone is a Creator, this fact is quite unlikely.
- Herobrine has his own realm, which is something that Creators have in common. Notch and Dinnerbone both have their own realms. Entity303 also has his own realm, which hints that he is a Creator, too.
- Herobrine is able to manifest a player to look like him. Notch, a Creator, is able to do such thing too, where he manifests Boop to look (almost) like him.
Herobrine Timeline Theory (Debunked - *ahem* *fills lungs* The swamp is under the control of the United Mob Association, Herobrine is a Creator and gave the vessels their own abilities, the White Eyed Demon is likely just Null and the wither skeletons are just Null's minions - Enderman are in both the Herobrine Forces and United Mob Association - so Null isn't ruling over the Nether or anything, Swordsman Herobrine didn't fight Blue Demon until the later episode because Dinnerbone intervened (more evidence of Dinnerbone having nothing to do with the Herobrine Forces other than being their sort of enemy, like seriously he doesn't even have ender powers he is literally just a creator nothing more nothing less (see what I did there?)), also where the part about Blue Demon you literally said some random stuff at the end about Blue Demon's backstory not being correct also Entity303 is Entity303 Jeb ain't gonna do anything till like AV69 or something I don't know and Steve was able to leave Blue Demon behind because random Illager King moment and also he is now angry and wants his sword back so yay)[]
By: MastermindsetX37
Ok this theory might seem long like the story your sixth grade teacher made you read.
The theory is about the herobrine storyline.
1.AV11-12 is the beggining of the appearance of herobrine and it looks like that herobrine orginated his forces in a swamp which shows where he recruited his witch forces which would later on make zombies work for herobrine.
2. in AV11 when herobrine number 1 made greg and chris rise up and make them become a herobrine, that was (probably) not far from the time that (most likely) herobrine claimed his powers from dinnerbone, now i specifically say dinnerbone because he posses ender powers which include teleportation, and that is what exactly happened in the observation in ep 42 and aslo seems to have the power to return and spawn ender dragons which can be only done in the end unless if its a creator.
3.after AV11 or 12, that is when mustard began thriving to know the truth and began working for herobrine and also when herobrine started to grow his sword and powers. and for some reason when a herobrine doppleganger lives longer his skin darkens and he gains more power, hence why master herobrine is nearly fully covered in black but his skin stop becoming black for some reason. and the only thing that is fully black but not powerful is null. there is multiple nulls in the series and the only that seems to be the most powerful is the white eye'd demon and somehow he has wither skeletons working for him that means he is ruling the nether untill the big axe piglin came or he had some connection to the wither or herobrine.
4. after a loooooooooong time master or swordsman herobrine fully progressed his sword which could potentially mean he was waiting the whole time to properly fight drowned. and maybe the reaper was for controlling his powers and summoning things.
and also just maybe drowned was lying to steve about his backstory and thus probably why jeb or disguised as entity 303 is trying to show steve the truth about drowned and trying to make him go away from him
Entity303 theory (Has now fought a creator in AV59, episode is literally called A Battle Among Creators) (Confirmed, I guess - Entity303 intended to advance Steve's abilities by allowing him to reconcile with his other aspects - Chris and Greg were already pretty decent with their aspects) (Oh yeah, and he is indeed not an anti-creator. He is just a regular run-of-the-mill creator)[]
By: RazyRapizYT
Entity303 are doing some weird things, first, he tried to stop the panda pirates, and then he captured steve in his realm two times already, and there is no reason for him to say anything to Steve, but my theory is that he is an enemy towards the united mob association, or something like that. He is an anti-creator, but he never fought the real creators, so that is more weirder, if he didn't do all that, I might think he might not be an anti-creator. But because I do not have much evidence to back up that, I can't say that he's not, but he has been doing some really weird thing lately, and why does he target Steve? Why not Chris or Greg? Why Steve? But maybe Steve is just the "Chosen one".
The United Mob Association's intents (Likely to be Confirmed - while the United Mob Association likely does not know of Boop's importance to the Villager Kingdom, and Notch only interacted with Boop while the UMA members there were unconscious, the other reasons listed are perfectly viable)[]
by: Baryonyx138
In Boop's arc, we've seen that the UMA has a strange interest with Boop, intending to bring him safely to the swamp. I think this is because Boop is the key to end the civil war once and for all.
This is because, Boop is related to many sides in the war. First of all, he is a villager and also the heir of the Villager Kingdom. Second, he has a close relations with a player, MrFudgeMonkeyz. Third, he has a personal communication with a Creator (Notch). And finally, he possesses Herobrine items and even has his own Herobrine form.
The true intentions of the Red-Robed Villager Noble (Simultaneously Debunked and Confirmed - the Red-Robed Noble is in fact fiercely loyal to the Villager King, but everything else about his character seems pretty realistic for someone who wants to keep the Kingdom on the track of villager supremacy)[]
by: Jutpa Da Bunny
I have a theory relating to the Red-Robed Villager Noble that may end up becoming reality.
So, we know that he exiled Mustard, and he wanted to have Boop disappear "for the sake of the Villager Kingdom". However, this would actually not help the Villager Kingdom in the slightest, especially with Boop. Mustard was already going against the Villager Kingdom's ideologies, so there was justification, but removing the only heir to the throne of the Villager Kingdom? If the Villager King were to die, then there wouldn't be anyone to take his place. Anyone, aside from the red-robed noble himself.
I think the Red-Robed Villager Noble actually wants to take over the Villager Kingdom and ensure it remains fixed on the one ideology of villager superiority - he doesn't care about the post-1.14 Villagers, sending in the armies to destroy the Alliance, while he is also trying to prevent any ideas of villager-player cooperation from entering the minds of the commoners by exiling Mustard.
The player tribe that attacked Fuzzy was actually The Resistance (Likely to remain a mystery)[]
Posted by LemonNumber
My theory is that the player tribe who attacked Fuzzy Cloud in the past actually was the early The Resistance.
- That would be one reason why he attacked the resistance players and helped Blue Demon.
- Three players in that tribe who attacked Fuzzy are apart of The Resistance tribe. Exterminator, Mr. Shadow and 303killyou
- Fuzzy Cloud might just wanted revenge.
Serafina will join the Resistance Deserters and the Resistance Deserters will later join the Alliance (Well, that one got Debunked so hard I'm honestly surprised at how fast that happened)[]
By: Jutpa
We know that Serafina is working with the remains of the Demoniac Voltage Reaver, which is a Herobrine item. We also know that those who come in contact with Herobrine items usually gain themselves some Herobrine powers. So, following through that logic, my theory is that Serafina gains Herobrine powers.
What does this have to do with her joining the Resistance Deserters and later the Alliance? EVERYTHING.
Because Grave is literally in Among Us mode, when Serafina reveals so much as 1% of her new Herobrine powers, he will immediately try to kill her. She will escape from death, being a major Patreon character, and will join the Resistance Deserters in retaliation.
Later on, the Resistance Deserters will find their way into the Alliance's territory. Chris will eagerly accept them into the Alliance, and as such Serafina turns from Supporting Antagonist to Supporting Protagonist like an absolute pro.